Hands down this is the most authentic pizza in the world including Italy, here it ' s all about the pizza, burnt to the right amount, bubbly and crusty to the right amount, soft and crunchy, tangy tomato sauce and the mozzarella even melted you can tell it was the freshest. more»

Also, my server, without asking me what size I wanted, gave me a large, pricier pizza ( trust me, me and my friend did not look like we needed a large ) which cost $ 22. more»

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc's Service - Select Comments

After reading some of these reviews it really sounds like someone has an axe to grind for them because I have never had bad service or slow delivery. more»

Our meal started out well -- friendly and quick service , charming atmosphere , and a nice eggplant parm appetizer. more»

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc's Ambiance - Select Comments

Price is not high at all The atmosphere is really friendly The only thing that I do not like about this place that is too faraway where I live and I can not eat it when I want. more»

I love the Thompson Street location , too , but the larger space and staff at this location can ' t be beat. more»

Top Sentiments among Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc Reviewers

Good italian pizza	Big Pizza Market
Great pastas	Authentic flavor
Fresh mozzarella	Fresh chow fun noodles
Excellent lunch specials	Great pizza spot
Great salads	Wonderful wine selection

See full list of what people liked about Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc»

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc, New York - 90%

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc Details

Reviews Summary for Salt & Pepper On First ... Read Reviews »

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc's Food - Select Comments

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc's Service - Select Comments

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc's Ambiance - Select Comments

Top Sentiments among Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc Reviewers

Salt & Pepper On First Avenue Inc, New York
- 90%